Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Next Steps for Solar

Solar PV prices have hit their bottom.... at least for now. So what's next for the solar industry? Gigaom's got a great article on financial and product innovation as the next steps. Read it below, and here.

A few years ago the biggest influence on the solar industry was the falling prices of solar cells, leading to some of the cheapest solar panels in history. But today, that solar panel price drop has slowed. Now solar companies are focusing on other ways to reduce costs and push the industry forward, including new types of solar panel financing, novel and more efficient panel designs and low-cost, next-gen batteries to pair with solar panels. At the solar industry conference Solar Power International, which kicked off Monday in Las Vegas, expect to hear all about the latest innovations from startups and big companies that are developing these new business models and new designs. Image courtesy of Apple.
Photo courtesy of Apple

Batteries and energy storage

For the past couple of years, batteries have taken center stage in the solar industry, and they’ve only gotten more attention in recent months thanks to Tesla’s big battery factory bet in Reno, Nevada, which will eventually churn out some batteries for the power grid. When paired with solar panels, batteries can store solar energy at night when the sun goes down, making solar systems available to provide power around the clock. However, battery systems add significant costs to the solar system. At SPI, solar service company Sunrun announced Monday morning that it has started a pilot project to offer battery systems from OutBack Power Technologies to its solar customers. Last week, startup Stem unveiled a partnership with Kyocera Solar to offer a solar panel and battery system for commercial customers. In the early stages of this market, partnerships can help small companies compete on a larger scale, and partnerships between nimble startups and big service providers can introduce more innovative thinking.
  Batteries ready to ship at Aquion Energy's factory. Image courtesy of Katie Fehrenbacher, Gigaom.

Batteries ready to ship at Aquion Energy’s factory. Photo by Katie Fehrenbacher, Gigaom. Of course, these companies aren’t the first to make partnerships across the solar/battery divide. SolarCity works with Tesla for its batteries (Tesla CEO Elon Musk is also chairman of SolarCity). One Roof Energy has been working with battery maker Silent Power to launch products. SunPower is working with KB Homes to provide a solar-panel-and-battery combo to new homeowners in Irvine, El Dorado Hills and San Diego. And SunEdison has piloted a battery from startup Seeo. Other grid and solar-focused battery startups are now working on the next generation of their battery chemistries. Awhile back, startup Aquion Energyswitched its anode-materials blend to a higher-energy, better-performing one.Battery startup Ambri has made changes to its chemistry as well. Startup Eos recently showed off its first zinc battery installation for New York utility Con Edison.

Financing

Offering less expensive ways to finance solar panel systems is another way to reduce overall solar project costs. Last week SolarCity announced the first registered offering of solar bonds, starting with a $200 million fund. The earnings on the solar bonds are paid for by the income from monthly solar energy payments from SolarCity’s customers. SolarCity has developed a booming business by enabling customers to pay for solar power as a monthly service, instead of having to pay for solar panel installations up front.
  SolarCity panels, image courtesy of SolarCity.
On Monday, reinsurer PartnerRe said it plans to offer $100 million toward financing purchasing loans originated by Mosaic, the crowdfunding solar startup based in Oakland. For now, crowdfunded solar projects make up a tiny fraction of solar systems, but Mosaic has been expanding its services to other types of solar financing.

“Soft costs”

Financing is part of the “soft costs” for solar. Soft costs include everything that has to do with installing solar panels on rooftops (and large solar projects in the desert, for that matter) except for the cost of making the actual solar hardware — so it’s things like permitting, financing, taxes, marketing and customer acquisition, labor and supply chain costs. When it comes to installing solar panels on the rooftops of homes across the U.S., soft costs made up a whopping 64 percent of the total cost of the system, according to a report out late last year from the National Renewable Energy Lab (relying on data from 2012).
  Solar panels, Image courtesy of Jon Callas, Flickr Creative Commons

According to GTM Research, most of the reductions in solar costs are coming from the “balance of systems” costs, which are improvements in the design, engineering, labor and financing for rooftop solar systems. And soft costs make up a major part of the “balance of systems” costs. GTM expects the cost of installing solar power to fall by 33 percent between 2013 and 2017, and only six percent of that will come from a drop in the solar module prices. According to the Solar Energy Industry Association’s latest report, the U.S. installed 1.13 GW of solar panels in the second quarter of 2014. That was up 21 percent over the second quarter of 2013, and represented the fourth-largest quarter for solar installations in the history of the market.

Saturday, October 11, 2014

"Environmentalism" is Dead


NPR's coverage of a recent PEW Research poll reaffirms an interesting trend in American life: The environmental movement is dead. While 44 percent of our grandparents generation self-identified as environmentalists, only 32 percent of Millennials today

Part of the issue is semantics. "Environmentalist" is just no longer a cool word, so Millenials, ever aware of the perceptions of others, just don't use it. My suspicion would be that the term will likely never return to its near 50% threshold that it enjoys with the generation that invented it.

But the death of "environmentalism" doesn't necessarily spell doom for the planet. It's not that kids these days don't care about the environment. Quite the opposite. Instead, I think it's that Millenials just don't like labels in general. "Environmentalist" is an adjective.

If PEW Research were to take a similar poll across generational groups around support for "sustainability," "climate action," "recycling," "clean energy innovation," and "environmental markets," and "ecosystem preservation," I think they would see that our generation is just as "environmentalist" as our parents and grandparents if not more so.

Indeed, from the ashes of "environmentalists," has risen a plethora of successor movements. A menagerie of conservationists, climate activists, locavores, sustainable foodies, green consumers, and green investors.

So don't fear for mother nature. The decline of environmentalism doesn't represent the decline of environmental progress. Instead, we making a healthy transition away form a focus on adjectives, and toward a focus on verbs. Actions are more important than labels anyway, so it's a shift I think can only be good for the movement and the planet.

Friday, September 19, 2014

Get Ready for the Solar Bull Market

If you are interested in or invested in solar, and have been paying attention to the market and the news in the past 6 months, you are a pretty happy person right now.

The industry is rolling along with tremendous inertia, on course to double in size every 24 - 30 months at recent growth rates. It kicked ass in 2013, expanding by roughly 35 percent in installed capacity. Worldwide, this meant 35 GW of new solar were built in 2013 alone, with analyst forecasts that 2014 will finish as an even bigger year, with 49 GW added. In the first quarter of 2014 has only continued to build steam. Nearly half of all the new power plants built around the world in 2013 were renewable, according to the latest Global Trends in Renewable Energy Investment Report, and in the first 6 months of 2014, more solar energy generation was added to the US grid than natural gas power. So much for the shale revolution. What we are about to witness is the solar revolution.

While exciting for environmentalists, these facts are not lost on the market. The Ardour Global Renewables Index was up 50%. The top solar stocks outperformed the market by 100s of percentage points (that's percentage points, not basis points). Here's a graph of what the annual solar installations have looked like in the past few years. This is not the cumulative figure.



But will these trends continue beyond the current hype? Or are we in the midst of a solar bubble? 

This is no bubble, and here are five big reasons why:

1. China 
China represents now a major source of both demand and supply in the solar industry, and they are putting it in the ground at a tremendous rate. China's goal of installing 8 GW of new rooftop solar by year end on top of the 13 GW already in existence is a strong source of global demand (China is the red in the above bar chart, clearly a significant portion of global demand). 

But China is not just installing solar at a breakneck pace, it's also manufacturing solar. Since China is now home to large chunks of the solar supply chain, as well as a considerable amount of final assembly, its unlikely that their aggressive policy-driven demand targets will slacken in the near future.

2. Financial Innovation 
One of the biggest challenges to solar has always been its high level of capital intensity, coupled with high perceived risk by investors. These two factors together result have traditionally resulted in higher financing costs for solar power. But this trend is finally winding down, never to return.

Several new financing structures have emerged to allow solar companies to capitalize on their future profits today, instead of having to wait for the 20-year payback period people think of. The first are solar-backed bonds, Solar backed bonds are a new structure, similar to mortgage backed bonds, that allow solar companies to bundle the future payments received from solar electricity sales to the grid and sell them to investors. In exchange for a modest 4% or 5% cut to entire investors, solar companies can use this structure to essentially cash out their 20-year power purchase agreements today. The capital is then freed up for further investment.

This year, Solar City issued its second set of these bonds to the tune of $200 million, and this market it just heating up.

Another financial innovation the Yield Co., operates similar, but uses an equity structure instead of debt to monetize future solar cash flows. NRG energy, a major national utility company, recently . debuted shares of its own Yield Co. in 2013 and the stock has already rewarded investors with a north of 75% return in just its first 12 months trading.

While these types of transactions are still small in relative terms, the fact that credible financial institutions like Credit Suisse, Goldman and BAML are underwriting them is a good sign that they are gaining traction and will become an increasingly attractive option for solar companies looking to finance rapid growth.


3. Costs are Plummeting, Moore's Law Style
The price of Solar PV panels dropped 99% from 1977 - 2014, and at an accelerating pace. 60% of that price drop has happened in the last three years - since 2011. Prices have plummeted so rapidly that even major financial institutions --not green groups-- are writing reports about the strategic threat solar poses to the natural gas industry.

The bottom line is that as prices continue to fall, solar has already reached the fabled point of "grid parity," in many places with or without subsidies. In plain English: solar in many places has hit the tipping point where its more expensive not to have solar than to have it.


4. Innovation in Grid-Scale Storage
One critique that has often be leveled against solar is its unpredictability. If only we had some sort of affordable battery technology, critiques argue, solar would make sense. Well, that time is also now. While battery storage is early in its technology innovation lifecycle, it's moving along at a rapid clip, driven in part by the demand created by an explosively growing solar PV market. Several small companies have recently raised capital to commercialize next generation grid-scale battery solutions, and Germany as usual is ahead of the game deploying these technologies at grid scale to prove the concept.

A new International Energy Agency study found that the grid should not have a problem absorbing all this new solar. Contrary to the frequent argument of renewable energy doubters, high penetrations of 30% should be achievable without economic disruption, according to the IEA. In California, the nation's largest grid operator announced it had a day in March this year where 18% of the grid's energy came from solar, and that in the future it believes it can absorb as much as 30% without a problem. California's solar capacity doubled 2013.

With the evidence mounting that our grid infrastructure has no problem integrating even relatively large proportions of solar generation even with current technology, even traditional coal-reliant utilities like Georgia Power and Tea Party groups are starting to get in line.

Long story short: 24/7 solar power is just around the corner.

5. Electric Car Symbiosis
Tesla is doing pretty well. If its sky-high stock price and P/E ratio is any indicator, investors as a whole are pretty bullish about electric mobility. Some interesting research out of UBS's Investment Bank has shown that solar and EV's are forming a symbiotic relationship that will be mutually beneficial to the momentum of both industries.

According to UBS, the combination of batteries, electric cars and solar power will put "enormous pressure" on the utility system by rapidly making centralized fossil-fuel based generation facilities obsolete.

So I'm pretty bullish on solar. Now you know why.


Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Repost: Why Liberals Shouldn't Be Afraid of Big Money

Jessica Church, one of the members of the Clean Energy Leadership Institute where I volunteer, recently penned this short and sweet piece that summarizes my back to business school logic at the Energy Collective:
By Jessica Church 
Liberals everywhere: It is time for a different kind of climate legislation. 
In order for the U.S. energy economy to power itself into the future, it must develop new relationships with Wall Street. This idea may not appeal to the populist column of renewables advocates, but there are good reasons why anyone interested in avoiding climate disaster needs to be open to this idea. 
For some context: When it comes to Congress, 2013 was a year of conflict and inaction. As a result, the American people faced a sixteen-day government shutdown, SNAP cuts, reductions in unemployment insurance, and partisan gridlock. The Federal government lacks the capacity to function, much less affect sweeping regulatory environmental legislation. 
At the same time, the top five Wall Street firms have collectively invested $50 billion in solar, wind and energy efficiency over the last three years. They’ve lobbied Congress for extensions of key renewable energy policies. And they’ve worked to make the biggest investment portfolios in the world cleaner. 
In 2013, Exxon Mobil spent over $13 million lobbying Congress. By contrast, SolarWorld, America’s largest solar manufacturer since 1975, spent only $257,000. Bolstering the efforts of renewable companies with Wall Street capital will help even the playing field in the halls of Washington. 
So even though it doesn’t appear that Congress is anywhere near passing comprehensive regulatory legislation, they might be able to come together and pass more laws that incentivize private and corporate investment in renewables, efficiency, and public transportation. As it currently stands, this type of legislation tends to inspire less partisan gridlock and fewer insults aimed at environmentalists. Why? Because it has the backing of a diverse coalition that includes both pro-renewable populists and Wall Street. 
And if the government cannot or will not pass the kind of regulatory legislation, it is imperative that climate concerned Americans seek out and promote other options. The hard truth is that transforming the U.S. economy from its current state into a green economy will require massive monetary investments, and that may require a change in thinking from the dedicated, creative minds of liberal environmentalists. 
Do you feel a little bit dirty? Like you’re compromising your principles… sliding over to the other side? Don’t. This is one of the most effective ways of ensuring that the United States economy will transform itself into a green economy. And that is something everybody, kombucha drinking–thrift store shopping–bike riding-environmentalists included, can get excited about. 
Incentivizing private investment with investment tax credits, production tax credits, and other mechanisms that work within the existing market will be the quickest and most effective way to ensure that the United States’ energy economy doesn’t get left behind.

Saturday, February 22, 2014

Doing Well and Doing Good: The Business for Good Summit

LBJ's Baine's report has coverage of our McCombs Business for Good Summit here. Re-printing their article in its entirety below:

The McCombs School of Business Net Impact Chapter is hosting its 6th annual summit on business and social impact. Formerly called the Sustainable Business Summit, The Business for Good Summit has broadened its scope to address some of the more meaningful questions about how business can be used as a platform to affect social and environmental change. Panelists at the Summit will discuss topics such as the role of technology in education, energy innovation and climate change, sustainable and responsible investment, and the role of entrepreneurship in international economic development.

The Summit comes at a time when those involved in international development are asking questions about how the private sector can be more involved in projects typical to governments and NGOs. Proponents of private sector involvement in social welfare projects feel that harnessing business and investment funds has the opportunity for great benefits. Government organizations, such as USAID, and NGOs are no longer solely responsible in addressing social and environmental wealth issues—businesses and investors have just as much at stake in a global environment that continues to embrace greater economic interconnectivity.

This trend signifies a shift in private sector perceptions and what their consumers and shareholders expect of them. With the advent of open source data and increased transparency, consumers and shareholders hold companies more accountable. There is heightened emphasis on not just shareholder value, but also the social value of company shares. Furthermore, as B4G Summit leader Sean Pool points out, there are new business opportunities for companies on board with these new norms.

“Take for example the micro-finance work that the Whole Planet Foundation is funding,” says Pool. “By providing credit to small business owners and entrepreneurs, the Whole Planet Foundation is injecting capital into parts of the world that desperately need it, and the result is a blossoming of businesses, job creation, and economic development. But these are loans, not aid. Which means the Foundation can re-invests this capital again and again”. Joy Stoddard, a Director of WPF, will be speaking on this and other topics at the Summit.

As policymakers and business leaders embark on new challenges in economic development, these challenges also beg new innovations and solutions. A smart and innovative company will run towards these challenges. Additionally, they could be rewarded by profit and the feel good sentiment of adding real value to the world.

Pool also notes that these business model shifts are significant to NGOs and governments as well. While old models of economic development depended on aid from donors, there is now a real opportunity to create new models that emphasize economic self-sustainability and continued growth, despite cuts in funding. This could mean that NGOs modify their models individually, or enter into partnerships with like-minded businesses and entrepreneurs.

As the private sector increases its role in social welfare impact, there undoubtedly will be new challenges obstructing clear progress. When asked about the challenges that businesses and investors face by embracing social impact strategies, Pool answered that this is why he and his colleagues are so excited about the Summit. Many of the panelists of the event have confronted these obstacles and will discuss their setbacks, experiences, and best practices in business based social impact.

The Business for Good Summit represents private and public sector convergence in social and economic development. Globalization has forced policymakers and business leaders to think critically about their missions and business models. Leaders that can think critically and creatively will lead this shift towards responsible investment and innovation, and hopefully, will lead the international community to a brighter future.

The Summit will take place between 2pm and 6pm on Tuesday February 25th at the McCombs School of Business. For more information and to register to attend, please visit the Summit website: http://www.utsummit.org/.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Investing for Impact

So, as everyone knows, I am very interested in how we put the vast amounts of private capital sloshing around in the market to productive and positive use for society. In particular, I'm intrigued by the possibility that there are potentially trillions of dollars out there to fund things like environmental sustainability, community revitalization, education, better governance, and other social causes. 

On February 25th, I'm going to be helping to host a panel on this topic as part of the UT Business for Good Summit. Here's the quick description: 

Investing for Impact

With $3.74 trillion invested in sustainable and responsible investment funds in the United States, we are rapidly approaching an era where even mainstream investors need to take into account the social, environmental, and community impacts of their investment decisions.

And the conversation no longer about “values” versus “value” in investing. In fact, the evidence is mounting that sustainable and responsible investing strategies actually can yield higher returns than strategies that ignore these factors. According to a 2012 Harvard Business School study, $1 invested in a portfolio comprised of “high sustainability” companies in 1993 would have been worth $22.60 by 2010. The same $1 invested in a control group would have only grown to $15.40.


In this dynamic and evolving space, large financial institutions are beginning to look beyond simple “responsible” investing metrics to create impact with their investments. Goldman Sachs recently announced the closing of deals around two new investment vehicles, “social impact bonds,” in which returns are explicitly linked to social justice or educational goals attainment.

This bodes well for those of us trying to use business for good.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Making R&D Count

This summer we saw big news out from the Bureau of Economic Analysis: Corporate research and development accounts are henceforth to be counted toward "investment" in the calculation of the GDP, rather than as expenses. This has big implications for technology companies, and for innovation policy.

Innovation-driven companies like Apple, GE, Samsung, Space-X and First Solar depend on investments in research and development to stay cutting edge. If they aren't on the cutting edge, they won't stay in business long (case-in-point, look at the recent decline in Apple's market valuation, driven not by any tangible problems with its balance sheet, but rather by the fear that its innovative edge on major money making devices is starting slip relative to its competitors).

But despite the value of R&D and the product and process improvement is leads to for companies that deal in innovation, under the old GDP accounting rules R&D could not be counted as an "investment" in something of future value. Only as an "expense," money gone and never to return.

This is cognitively wrong, since it is clear that investments in new technology can be incredibly lucrative, if uncertain. The explanation for this has of course been the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) is a notoriously conservative entity, and to allow companies to book "investments" in the uncertain future value of innovation would be too risky. Thus, they have always been counted as expenses, and where such expenses have resulted in a better product, the value is later booked as profit. Part of why Apple exploded into the place of most valuable company in the world in 2011 was because of years and decades of investments in R&D that led to better technology.

The advanced technology they developed for iPod, iPhone, and iPad (3 key pillars of Apple's success) were kept off the books, written down as "expenses," rather than being carried appropriately as intellectual assets.

While FASB's Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) still have not changed, the Bureau of Economic Analysis's latest GDP estimate set a new precedent this week by treating past investments in R&D as they should be: as investments in intellectual assets—rather than as expenses. In Europe, such accounting is already commonplace, and fully legal under European accounting rules. But the restrictive US-dominated GAAP system has yet to accept the importance of R&D and intellectual property to value creation.

The BEA's move will have the immediate impact of increasing the US GDP this year, and every past year going back to 1929. And it makes complete sense.

Companies carry "intangible assets" on their balance sheets all the time. Coca-Cola company for example, carries a roughly $70 billion "goodwill" asset that simply represents the "goodwill" that global consumers have toward their brand.

If goodwill is allowed on balance sheets, shouldn't investments in intellectual property, innovation, and R&D be counted as assets? This week, the BEA showed that it thinks they should, and that's a great step. But while this will be great for macoeconomic innovation policy, there is much further to go. I have written a lot (see the innovation chapter in Progressive Growth) about how to accelerate innovation in the economy, but this accounting realization adds this potentially potent tool to the toolbelt:

If the FASB would revise GAAP to count R&D as investments in assets rather than as expenses, it would go a long way toward incentivizing companies to spend more on R&D, a net social positive. When companies have a bad year, short-sighted CEOs being evaluated on their stock price often look for the longest term spending to cut first. Because R&D is accounted for as spending, rather than investments in assets, it is often first to the chopping block, much to the detriment of our national innovation economy and national prosperity.

Changing the GAAP rules to be more permissible of accounting for R&D and intellectual property as assets could go a long way toward encouraging companies to invest in innovation. Even better: unlike the R&D tax credit, this change would be virtually free to the taxpayer, and would start yielding economic returns almost immediately.