Wednesday, October 16, 2013

"Think [Very] Different:" An Ambitious Strategy to Turn Around Apple's Growth Prospects

Much reporting has been flowing through the business press about what to do with the more $140 billion mountain of cash that is figuratively sitting in Apple's treasure chest in Cupertino. One prominent investor who recently bought $1.5 billion of Apple stock has come forward advocating for a massive equity buy-back as one option to push the value back up, while others say Apple must invest in its own future if it is to ever grow again. Despite continued earnings growth, the company's share price is still 25% off its peak above $700. Why? 

Underlying most analyses are a widespread fear that Apple no longer has what it takes to innovate without Jobs. Essentially, the market had priced in a very high share price based on future growth opportunities viewed to be limitless so long as Steve Jobs's creative brain was at the helm. The release of the iPad three years ago and the ensuing opening up of an entire new industry of e-readers—products that consumers didn’t know the needed—propelled Apple’s stock to stratospheric highs. Investors were convinced that Apple’s wizards could continue to out-innovate everyone, and were rewarded by soaring stock values.

Now, three years later, Apple’s stock sags under the weight of heavy expectations. To be fair, it has only been 3 years since apple revolutionized the e-reader and possibly the laptop business with the ipad. Since then, incremental advances and improvements have carried them along reinforced their position of dominance. But, copy-cats have eaten away at their market share. Android has leapt to the front of the pack, and all indications suggest that they have more room to grow. Windows phone like-wise has slowly but surely eaten its way into the market. Kindle Fire and HD are now credible and cheap alternatives to the ipad, slowly displacing market share.

Meanwhile, Apple is building a multi billion dollar facility in California to serve as its global headquarters. As an investor, I usually get suspicious when companies start spending their excess cash on massive extravagant homages to themselves, instead of innovation to stay ahead of the game. 

Investors have punished Apple, and rightly so. Its products are no longer unique in a marketplace devoid of competitors. Indeed, Apple’s competitive advantage in existing markets seems less certain than ever. Investors who are buying Apple at its recent low of $400 are hoping that its market cap and fundamental will carry it, or else that its next product, the iWatch, or a new and improved iTV will do again for their respective industry what the iPad did for e-reader: convince consumers to shell out hundreds of dollars for entirely re-imagined products they never knew they needed.

But many are not so optimistic. And this puts pressure on Apple. If it can not deliver another market-revolutionizing product, investors may forever take their money elsewhere, keeping its stock firmly tethered to earth for the foreseeable. On the other hand, if it tries and fails, things could be much worse. With all eyes on Apple, what’s a company to do?


Maybe the Solution is on the Roof

Why not move to an adjacency in consumer electronics: solar panels. They are consumer electronics, that just happen to go on your rooftop. And the industry is presently in a moment of supreme existential reevaluation.

Recently news broke that Apple would be building its second solar-powered data facility in the Nevada desert. But while media outlets like Reuters and Cleantechnia gave the company the obligatory pat on the back for good implementation of its environmental policy, no one asked the real question:

With the energy sector in such need of revolution, and Apple such an expert industry revolutionizer, couldn't Apple play a larger role as not just customer, but creator of clean tech?

Given the ambivalence of both the media and markets toward Apple’s potential for future innovation (it's stock has slid nearly 40 percent since its high of $702 last fall), a bold move toward innovation in an industry where innovation is sorely needed could do more than just save the planet. It could save Apple.


1. Apple needs to 'Think Different'

Apple is facing an interesting conundrum that only the second richest company in the world could face: It has too much money than it knows how to spend on its core business. Faced with this, Apple's leadership has opted to take what for any other company would be a safe move: paying off their shareholders with dividends and stock buybacks.

‘Safe,’ that is, for anyone but Apple. For the world's preeminent innovation role model, breaking a long-standing tradition of keeping revenues for reinvestment in future growth shows weakness, not strength. Instead of signaling to investors that Apple was a great bet on value, Apple's little bribes to its investors signaled that the company was out of game-changing ideas to invest in.

It has only been 3 years since Apple revolutionized e-readers, home computing, and possibly reading itself, with the iPad; 5 years since it changed how humans interact with each other and with the internet with the iPhone; and 12 since the iPod put the music industry finally and firmly on the path of digitization. But since then, Apple’s output has plateaued. Android has leapt to the front of the pack in smart phones operating systems, and all indications suggest that it has more room to grow. Windows phone similarly has slowly but surely eaten its way into the market. Kindle Fire and HD are now credible and cheap alternatives to the ipad, slowly displacing market share, even as the industry overall continues to grow.

Being on top makes you a big target, and just about every major device maker in the world has Apple in its sights. If Apple is going to regain its position as the world's preeminent authority in all things innovation, it's going to need to take its own advice, and "think different."


2. The Energy Industry is Ripe for Disruption

First of all, climate change is scary.

Second of all, energy is one of the largest and yet least innovative industries in the world. Roughly one out of every ten dollars spent globally is spent on energy, and 8 of the top 10 largest companies on Fortune's 500 list of biggest global companies make either oil, cars, or engines (the only two companies in the top-10 who don't are Apple and Warren Buffet's Berkshire Hathaway).

But despite being one of the biggest industries globally, energy companies are remarkably lazy when it comes to research and development, spending  just 0.42 percent of revenue on average on new technology, according to the Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, or EERE. This is compared to an average of 7.9 percent in the electronics industry, and 20 percent in pharmaceuticals

This means that the transmission infrastructure technologies we use in many parts of the country hasn't really been updated since the 1950s. Power plants we have running today were built in the 1960s. And despite the rapid growth of data-enabled smart devices, our electricity storage, metering, appliances, heating, cooling, and transportation systems have for the most part remained unchanged for decades.

This dearth of innovation makes energy a sitting duck, and a substantial market opportunity for a well-resourced and ruthless innovator like Apple. We all saw that iTunes did to the then-teetering record publishing industry in 2001. Imagine Apple bringing that same innovative force to bear on the now-teetering fossil fuels industry. 


3. Apple has the financial capital

The pittance of capital trickling into energy R&D means would-be innovators are hungry for cash. And Apple has cash. Mountains of cash.

Just for a sense of scale: What Apple spends on R&D on OS X, iOS, hardware, and its other products in one year ($4 billion is projected for FY 2013) would run the federal government's Advanced Research Projects Agency for Energy, or ARPA-E comfortably for eight years. With the $140 billion Apple had sitting idle in the bank at the beginning of this year, it could have funded ARPA-E at its current funding level for 500 years.

Even more ambitious, taking into account both ARPA-E and the Department of Energy’s larger, older, and more established applied clean energy research program run by the office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, a roughly $2 billion research program in 2013—Apple could have run the entire federal clean energy technology research and development program at its current level for more than 50 years. Again, this is just with the cash Apple has today.

While it might not be wise to blow all of the company's cash on a clean technology research shopping spree, the astounding figures indicate that if Apple wanted to be a contender, it could be. Looking at the private sector instead of at the government, with the cash Apple has on hand, it could buy a commanding position in every single US-based clean tech company to receive venture funds in the last decade, and still have $100 billion left over.


4. Apple has the intellectual and physical capital

Of course, transforming the U.S. energy industry is not as simple as buying up patents, technologies, or companies wholesale. The right team with the right tools and the right vision is also needed, but there again Apple has assets to bring to bear.

Apple's existing supply chain relationships and size-based negotiating leverage, its research, development, prototyping, and manufacturing capabilities, and its formidable intellectual property portfolio all position Apple well to revolutionize clean energy. Apple’s existing patents on battery, charging, dynamic data management, and even solar technologies could serve a springboard for a broader foray away from powering their consumer devices and toward becoming a major innovator and supplier of clean technology components.

Whatever additional IP it needed, Apple could license, buy, or invent. Exactly what kind of clean tech devices Apple might want to make would be anyone's guess. They are, after all, the innovators.

Perhaps Apple would want to start small, sticking to what it knows with consumer-focused home clean energy and energy efficiency technologies, like smart thermostats. Apple could buy Nest, a zesty startup that is quietly doing to thermostats what the ipod did to music players. Or maybe Apple would want to create super user-friendly, easy-to-install solar panels to charge your appliances, power your home, or sell energy to the grid. Maybe Apple would develop smart meters that seamlessly send real-time home electrical consumption data to your iPhone or OS X dashboard, alert you when an appliance has been left on, and saves all data to your iCloud account. This would of course all be presented with the sleek, elegant, and simple design sensibilities that are Apple's calling card.


5. Apple has the human capital

The notion that Apple could revolutionize clean energy is not new. Greenpeace laid out a “Clean Energy Roadmap for Apple” last summer calling on the company to go coal free and power its data centers with 100 percent renewable energy. But where Greenpeace and other commentators leave off is exactly where Apple has the potential to pick up: Apple has the potential to be not just a consumer but a creator of disruptive clean technology innovations.

Apple's people are the best in the world at re-imagining and rapidly reinventing entire sectors of the economy. They introduced a step-change in the consumer experience of personal computing in the late 90's, then music in the early 2000's, phones in the mid 2000's, and now books, games, movies and our entire digital experience with the iPad in 2009. With nearly infinite resources at their disposal, and the ability to bring on new expertise as needed, there is no reason to doubt that the company's innovative ethos couldn't apply to energy as it has to personal computing, communications, and media.

The notion that a company with such a keen focus on one industry (consumer electronics) could branch out into something so seemingly different may seem at first counterintuitive. But then, look at the history of corporate entities. Google got its start in search, but now makes mobile operating systems, email, maps, calendars, glasses, and self-driving cars. IMB got its start in mainframes, then made personal computers, and now has a successful global B2B technology solutions consulting business. Nokia was founded as a paper mill in the late 1800s and now is a major wireless carrier. And 3M, the company that makes Scotch Tape, among thousands of other brands, was founded in 1902 as the Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company, and sold a popular chemical to grinding wheel manufacturers.

Perhaps most iconic, the presence of Richard Branson’s Virgin Group in more than a dozen unrelated consumer-facing industries proves that corporate evolution into new markets is neither new nor unusual. And it may be time for Apple to evolve, or descend into irrelevance as it is slowly consumed by competition from its own copy-cats.

Apple is at the height of its power, wealth, and brilliance. In this moment, Tim Cook has a decision to make: whether Apple will count its blessings, spend its cash on stock buybacks and dividends that do not advance innovation or open new longterm growth trajectories, and settle in for a slow decline as competitors slowly whittle away at its dominance in favored sectors. Or, whether Apple will once again “think different,” and take a once-in-a-century opportunity to bring its innovative muscle to new markets ripe for revolution.

Sunday, August 25, 2013

Less Knowledge Is Less Power

With little fanfare, we recently passed a major technological milestone: the sale of the one-billionth Internet-enabled smartphone worldwide. About one in seven humans on earth hold the Internet in their hands – not bad for a technology that hardly existed 10 years ago. Worldwide sales of smart tablets, a technology barely three years old, exceeded 100 million units in 2012 and are set to surpass 600 million in the next few years.
That's the opening to the latest op-ed I helped put together and place with my friend Neal Lane for US News and World Report. Neal is a top-notch writer and innovation policy advocate, and a pleasure to work with.

It's amazing how much this story—of how innovation is what drives economic growth—is so taken-for-granted in the circles I travel, and yet still seems novel to vast swarths of the American public. In progressive economic policy, in business school, and in science and technology circles, the idea that innovation, both radical and incremental, is responsible for better economic outcomes is not only taken for given, it's taken for granted. Yet each time we work on one of these projects, the press treats it like a totally novel concept.

Part of the issue is that the innovation policy community lacks a strong communications push or much coordination to help keep these messages going, with perhaps the notable exception of folks like Neal DeGrasse Tyson and Bill Nye. We need to keep elevating folks like Neal, like Bill, and like Neal Lane to continue to grow our American culture of Innovation and ensure we send leaders to Washington who are prepared to make the rational investments we need to educate, innovate, build, and grow.

The rest of the article, reprinted from US News and World, is below:
This isn't just good news for web lovers and email addicts – these exploding markets represent tremendous sources of economic growth and job creation across the entire value chain, from manufacture, to infrastructure, to retail, to app development. The global smartphone market was estimated to be worth $219 billion last year, while the iPhone 5 alone was thought to have added as much as 0.5 percent to the GDP of the United States in the fourth quarter of 2012. These billions of dollars translate into millions of jobs.
The idea that new technological innovations are major drivers of economic growth is not new. In fact, economist Robert Solow won the Nobel Prize for his observation that roughly half of the U.S.'s economic growth since the 1950s could be attributed to technological advancement.
This inextricable relationship between technology and prosperity is why it's particularly troubling to see the severe cuts to federal science and technology programs continuing under the sequester. After all, it has often been public investments in science and engineering research that have paved the way for robust private sector growth in new American industries.
Of course, Apple and its competitors created this new industry. But the technologies that make smart phones and tablets possible came from discoveries made through federally funded research. According to one analysis by Research Trends, the technologies used in LCD screens, lithium-ion batteries, digital hard drive storage and Internet protocols – all critical to these success of these devices – were enabled by key research discoveries funded by the National Science Foundation, National Institutes of Health and the Departments of Energy and Defense.

None of this research was carried out with a smartphone or tablet in mind. It is simply not possible to say in advance where fundamental research will lead – but without the research, revolutions like this one won't happen.

Beyond tablets and smartphones, some of the United States' most economically important industries, from aerospace to biotechnology to software, can be traced to an alphabet soup of federal research programs – NASA, DARPA, NIST, DoD, NSF, NIH, DoE, and others. One analysis drew a direct connection from the United States' $750 billion biotechnology industry to a $3.6 billion investment in the Human Genome Project, which had the support of four presidents. Another showed that each year the National Institutes of Health generates twice as much economic benefit as it costs to run.

When I served as President Clinton's chief advisor for science and technology, I saw both Republicans and Democrats rally around a number of bipartisan innovation initiatives, such as funding for the National Nanotechnology Initiative and the completion of the first draft sequence of the human genome. Though it was a time of deep partisan division on many issues, we found we could agree that government investments in research were critically important to the future of the economy.
America is at an economic crossroads. The current path of austerity leads to ever diminishing returns – cutbacks on research and training of future scientists and engineers, slowdowns in technological innovation and fewer high quality jobs for Americans down the road. The right path for the country is increased investment in research and innovation, which history has shown reliably yields a high return.
Shutting off the sequester and any other science-cutting measures that Congress may be considering and restoring funding for critical research is an essential and urgent first step. But we need to go further.
An insightful report by the Center for American Progress called "300 Million Engines of Growth," outlinesan aggressive vision for reinventing the U.S. innovation system for the 21st century. It advocates placing the budgets of three key federal research agencies on a sustainable doubling path, making sure we get the most we can out of our national labs, and investing in grand challenges in the form of what it calls "Frontier Prizes" that can push the boundaries of science and engineering.
In an increasingly globalized and digitized world, nations across the globe recognize that knowledge quite literally is power. Members of Congress who place austerity above all else need to ask themselves how falling back from the frontiers of knowledge is somehow good for the economy. I have yet to hear that argument.
Neal Lane is a former science advisor to President Bill Clinton and currently a Professor at Rice University.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

11 Tips for Future CEOs from a McCombs Leader

Some words of wisdom from William Cunningham, former UT president and system chancellor, and McCombs Dean.

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

Obama's Second Term Climate Resurrection

I watched Obama's climate speech last night with my parents, sisters, and grandparents yesterday in Seattle. We all huddled in rapt attention, analyzing everything the president said and hoping to glean some insight about what we can expect.

Overall, I give the president an A on rhetoric, and a B+ on substance. He did just about everything he could feasibly do using executive authority. Of course, he should have done it all 3 years ago immediately after the failure of the Kerry-Boxer / Kerry-Graham-Liberman bills in the senate.  And, to get the A on substance, he would have had to have explicitly pledged to meet the 17% Copenhagen commitment that we made to the world, and put in place regulation in all industries (not just power) to meet that. The Supreme Court says he has the authority. Yes, I keep the bar high.

Heather Zichal of the White House has a great post debunking anti-science myths that I couldn't resist reposting is here:

The President’s Plan to Reduce Carbon Pollution: Myths v. Reality

Yesterday, at Georgetown University, President Obama laid out his Administration’s broad-based plan to cut carbon pollution and meet the climate change challenge.

It’s a plan that starts with responsibility. While no single step can reverse the effects of climate change, President Obama believes we have a moral obligation to future generations to do what we can.  After all, this is no longer a distant threat – we are already feeling the impacts now.
The 12 hottest years on record have all come in the last 15 years. Asthma rates have doubled in the past 30 years and our children will suffer more asthma attacks as air pollution gets worse. And increasing floods, heat waves, and droughts have taken a toll on our nation’s farmers, which is raising food prices. These changes come with far-reaching consequences and real economic costs. Last year alone, there were more than 11 different weather and climate disaster events with estimated losses exceeding $1 billion each across the United States.

During President Obama’s first term, we took a number of important steps to reduce carbon pollution and spark innovation in cleaner forms of energy. For example, we doubled our use of renewable electricity from wind, solar, and geothermal sources and set the toughest fuel efficiency standards in American history. Thanks in part to these actions, in 2012, U.S. carbon pollution from the energy sector fell to the lowest level in nearly 20 years. To build on this progress, the President’s Climate Action Plan has three pillars: cut carbon pollution in America; prepare the United States for climate impacts; and lead international efforts to combat global climate change.

Now, we’re already seeing many Republicans and some of the nation’s biggest polluters attack the President’s plan. And they’re recycling the same tired and empty arguments that we’ve heard time and time again. To separate fact from fiction, let’s dig a little deeper and compare their rhetoric with the reality.

Claim #1:

Reducing carbon pollution will hurt the economy and cost jobs.

FACT:

Over the last three decades, we have reduced carbon pollutants by more than half and have doubled economic growth.
 
Our own history shows us that we can protect our environment, reduce harmful pollution, and promote economic growth all at the same time. And the numbers speak for themselves: between 1970 and 2011, aggregate emissions of common air pollutants dropped 68 percent, while the U.S. gross domestic product grew 212 percent. Private sector jobs increased by 88 percent during the same period.

What’s even worse about this claim is that it suggests a lack of faith in American businesses to innovate. When we banned cancer-causing chemicals in our toys, and leaded fuel in our cars, it didn’t end the plastics industry or the oil industry; American chemists came up with better, cheaper substitutes.  When we phased out chlorofluorocarbons – the gases that depleted the ozone layer – it didn’t kill off refrigerators and air conditioners; American workers built better ones.

The bottom line is that we don’t have to choose between the health of our children and the health of our economy. Those goals go hand in hand. And by taking action to reduce carbon pollution, we can spark new jobs and industries building cleaner and more efficient American-made energy technologies.

Claim #2:

Regulating carbon pollution will increase energy bills for consumers.

FACT:

Utility industry leaders say they can reduce carbon pollution without raising bills.
 
We know how to use the tools of the Clean Air Act in a way that reduces pollution and protects American families and businesses.

For example, when the President announced historic fuel economy standards, the critics said cars would get smaller, more expensive for consumers, and hurt sales. They were wrong. Today, car sales are at multi-year highs, people are already saving money at the pump thanks to greater efficiency, and we’ve preserved consumer choice. In March, EPA released a new report which showed that, compared to just five years ago , Americans have twice as many hybrid and diesel vehicle choices, a growing set of plug-in electric vehicles, and six times as many vehicle choices with fuel economy of 30 mpg or higher.

When it comes to the power sector, the utility industry itself admits that they can reduce carbon pollution without raising bills. Moreover, to protect consumers, the President directed the EPA to develop standards in an open and transparent way, provide flexibility to different states with different needs, and build on the leadership that many states, cities, and companies have already shown.  And that’s exactly what they’ll do. Separately, the Administration will also continue efforts to make household appliances more efficient, savings consumers hundreds of billions on utility bills through 2030.

At the same time, renewable energy has never been more affordable. It’s not only creating good jobs across the country, it’s providing clean, safe, and secure power to millions. And as costs continued to fall, both the wind and solar industries had their best year ever in America in 2012. Today, nine states get more than 10 percent of their electricity from wind and two of those – Iowa and South Dakota – get more than 20 percent. These trends just wouldn’t be happening if clean energy weren’t competitive and cost-effective for consumers.

Claim #3:

The Administration is waging a war on coal.

FACT:

President Obama has invested more in clean coal technology than any other Administration in history.
 
The President believes that America must take a leadership role in developing and manufacturing technologies that allow us to burn coal more cleanly and efficiently. Achieving that goal will also boost our economy, promote public health, and position the United States as the leader in the global clean energy race. That’s why President Obama has invested nearly $6 billion in clean coal technology and research and development – the largest such investment in U.S. history. And as part of the President’s Climate Action plan, he announced yesterday that the Administration will make up to $8 billion in loan guarantee authority available for a wide array of advanced fossil energy and efficiency projects to support investments in innovative technologies.

Cutting carbon pollution will help modernize our coal power plants. It will help spark innovation to create new clean energy technologies and it will put Americans to work with good jobs that can’t be shipped overseas making our power plants more efficient, which will save families money.

Claim #4:

President Obama won’t work with Congress.

False.

Each year President Obama has been in office, he asked Congress to come up with a common-sense, market-based solution to reduce carbon pollution and speed the transition to cleaner sources of energy. And he’s still willing to work with anyone in Congress to make that happen. But as he said in his State of the Union Address, if Congress didn’t act soon, his Administration would because this challenge demands our attention now.
 
The plan the President released yesterday followed through on that commitment. For the sake of future generations we cannot delay efforts to reduce carbon pollution and prepare the country for a changing climate. We cannot afford to lose the clean energy race and the new jobs and industries that come with it. And we cannot miss the opportunity to engage the world and catalyze action to tackle this challenge.

The fact is that there is a lot of money to be made by the companies who best-position themselves for the new energy economy to which we are already transitioning (recall: in the past 4 years we've doubled renewable energy without hardly a single new coal plant... ford and Chevy both have plug in electric hybrids on the market and Nissan has an all-electric). So we are in the middle of this. Kudos for Obama and his speechwriters for telling it like it is.

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

10 Rules for Entrepreneurship Ecosystems from Babson

Someone over at Babson College Entrepreneurship Center (cutely called, BEEP), has the right idea about entrepreneurship ecosystems. Here are their 10 rules (reprinted) for entrepreneurship ecosystems. A lot of wisdom here, I'll have to return to this to comment in more depth.
  1. Stop emulating Silicon Valley! Even Silicon Valley could not create itself today if it were starting from scratch. Give up on thoughts of a “knowledge-based society” or “the information economy.” You don’t need to tell entrepreneurs that they need to use Internet and mobile technologies anymore than you need to tell them to use water or electricity.
  2. Tailor an ecosystem around your own particular characteristics. Sustainable entrepreneurship is the result of numerous forces working together, which we call the entrepreneurship ecosystem. Each region has a unique ecosystem with more than a dozen elements.  Are there large companies that are used to interacting with small, innovative suppliers? Are there markets close by? Is the human capital technical in orientation? Does the culture support risk taking and innovative, contrarian thinking? Is leadership overtly and clearly supportive of entrepreneurship?  You need to understand all of them, and how they can be strengthened and aligned.
  3. Engage the entrepreneurship stakeholders early on. Entrepreneurship is about engagement and empowerment. Stakeholders should be engaged early in the process. This includes the various segments of the private sector, educational leaders, community leaders, government officials, entrepreneurship development organizations, leaders of diaspora networks, university officials, investors and lenders, and so on. In some communities the cooperatives, unions, and even religious organizations are influential. There are many ways to engage, but ongoing, sincere, open dialog is the most important starting point.
  4. Support the high potential entrepreneurs. Although entrepreneurship is inclusive, to jumpstart an entrepreneurship ecosystem, the most impactful sector to influence is the high ambition, growth oriented, market-seeking ventures. These create the jobs, the dynamism and vitality, and the growth.
  5. Get some visible successes, even by “brute force” if necessary. Success breeds success. Endeavor [LINK TO http://www.endeavor.org/ ] has built its entire strategy around this principle, finding and nurturing “high impact entrepreneurs.” This happens because: (a) successful entrepreneurs like to help other entrepreneurs; (b) successful entrepreneurs become angel investors; (c) successful entrepreneurs make excellent board members; (d) success inspires latent-entrepreneurs to take the leap; and, (e) successful entrepreneurs become powerful voices for governmental reform. According to the law of small numbers: it only takes a few successes to change the entire game. But when you see some successes on the horizon, make sure you celebrate them! Give a medal, an award, make them visible.
  6. Change the culture head on. Many leaders believe that this takes generations, and although much societal change is long term, there are certain social norms that can be changed in a few years: it is possible to increase tolerance for risk, the legitimacy (even nobility) of launching your own business, acceptance for honest failure. Media campaigns, annual events, and awards all help. Just think if you ran an entrepreneurship campaign as seriously as your own campaign for re-election?
  7. Stress the roots: don’t provide easy money. Early stage capital is always scarce, everywhere. But moving to the opposite extreme is equally disastrous. Provide funding, but insist that the entrepreneur bring in a matching investor. Keep the funding off the ventures’ balance sheets. Make sure the funds are not equity: government has no business selecting and nurturing winners. Directly incentivize the financial intermediaries, not the ventures themselves: make it easier for banks, private equity, angel investors, family businesses, and leasing companies to invest in the ventures themselves. Don’t be an evergreen financer: figure out a way to start the private financing markets, and get out, or focus on the highest risk areas.
  8. Pave the footpath. Don’t push clusters too hard. Every government now has a cluster strategy and thinks that will get entrepreneurship going, but success is elusive and rare. Clusters don’t create entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs create clusters. Mike Porter said that in 1999, only no one listened. Watch where the entrepreneurs are walking, and then pave the footpath. Remember, entrepreneurship is inherently a contrarian activity, so wherever you decide they should be, the good entrepreneurs will always be figuring out how to do something else, do it differently, and do it better. Identify, watch, encourage, support.
  9. Remove bureaucratic obstacles for entrepreneurs. Eliminate roadblocks and red tape through consolidation and streamlining. Redeploy the dozens or hundreds of clerks whose seats depend on their ability to slow everything down. Have permitting “bootcamps” to free up log jams. Make regulations transparent and provide tools for entrepreneurs to address them. Get rid of outmoded obstacles to redeploying people–support and retrain the unemployed rather than preventing their firing. Make sure tax collections are rigorous, fair, but entrepreneur-friendly. As a government purchaser, buy from small suppliers, but make sure you pay on time: nothing is as demotivating as doing a good job as a new company, and waiting three months to get paid: this is absolutely unforgivable and has a huge dampening effect on entrepreneurship.
  10. Experiment relentlessly and holistically. You can learn from what others have done around the world, but you have to experiment based on your own reality. Focus initially on short run experiments, small scale funding, short courses, and small numbers of entrepreneurs. Develop a norm of reflecting and learning from mistakes as well as successes. But don’t expect piecemeal action to work: you need to move different elements of the ecosystem simultaneously. To use a simple example, creating private equity will be self-defeating if there is no high potential deal flow for investors to invest in, and ways for them to realize (“exit”) their investment.

Saturday, March 30, 2013

"On faking it till you make it"

An interesting article in BI on faking it till you make it. it seems that social science is pretty clear. Though there is less agreement in literature:

"As Nathaniel Hawthorne wrote in The Scarlet Letter:

'No man, for any considerable period, can wear one face to himself, and another to the multitude, without finally getting bewildered as to which may be the true.'

But, to counter, the main theme of “Don Quixote” was:

'If you want to be a knight, act like a knight.'"

Perhaps both are true, to a degree. In fact, they may actually be getting at the same thing.

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Corporate America should put value before profit

A great synopsis of what's wrong with our corporate system:

www.businessinsider.com/companies-focus-on-value-not-profit-2013-3

...Now, if we could only start talking about how to fix it.